Homemade vanilla lip balm. You might have to let them cool and repeat several times to get the finished look you want. 11.06.2018 Faejinn No apologies. Hmm…maybe you are right. How important is it? Looking for a way to moisturize your lips? Is there anything that can be added to the current recipe to make it more of cream that you can see? Vanilla will flavor the lip balm; however, food coloring will not work to color it! There was an error submitting your subscription. Needless to say I have thrown out all 4 eos lip balm.